From The Grio— The results of a recent poll suggest that the majority of Americans believe the ongoing oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is worse than the damage caused by Hurricane Katrina, a category 5 storm which devastated the city of New Orleans and other cities along the Gulf in 2005.

I couldn’t disagree more. And I believe if the American public was better informed of the facts, they would too. The truth of matter is 11 people lost their lives on April 20, 2010 when the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig exploded. 17 others were injured. The resulting damage to the ecosystem of the Gulf of Mexico has left hundreds of fishermen without jobs and income for the foreseeable future. The U.S. government, led by President Obama, has remained committed to understanding the causes and resolution of the tragedy since its occurrence and has responded with the full force of the tools at their disposal.

Admittedly, the Obama White House initially responded in a measured and deliberate way, largely because the fire which lasted 48 hours, and the conflicting reports from BP executives in the first week, made it difficult to understand the full implications of the situation. Hurricane Katrina left approximately 1,836 people dead and hundreds more unaccounted for. In addition, thousands more lost their homes and livelihoods.

The damage from that disaster remains prevalent today: nearly five years later, thousands of displaced residents in Louisiana and Mississippi are still living in trailers. When the levee system catastrophically broke, waters reached 12 miles inland pushing houses and cars with it. Republican president George W. Bush famously praised the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) director, Michael Brown, who was incompetent, ineffective, and later forced to resign.

The scope of lack of governmental response to the Katrina disaster, the estimated loss of life and the $81 billion in total property damage make it the most costly storm in American history. Any attempt at equating the oil spill with Katrina is another far-right effort to attack Obama’s White House and undermine his authority and legitimacy as an effective leader.

On August 29, 2005 the force of Hurricane Katrina led to 53 levee breaks — flooding 80 percent of the city of New Orleans. Most of the coastal towns of the state of Mississippi were devastated or destroyed. FEMA had been tracking the storm for a week, but did not coordinate federal and state response teams. FEMA only provided housing for one fifth of the people who needed it, and encouraged state officials to not act for fear of interfering with the federal mandate. George W. Bush was widely criticized for being AWOL during the response effort, and inquiries into the lack of federal efforts are still being debated in Congress.

It seemed to be the first time that Americans became keenly aware that the richest nation on earth which is often so effective at providing billions in aid to foreign countries, for war efforts or in response to natural disasters, was completely unprepared to assist its own citizens within its own borders. This nation has consistently promoted democracy abroad, but did not guarantee the benefits of the wealth of that democracy for its own people. The trillion dollars spent over the last decade in Iraq make the Bush administration’s lackluster response to Katrina almost farcical.

The Gulf oil spill provides a unique challenge for the Obama White House, but not one for which he is unprepared. He has already coordinated efforts of the Coast Guard, FEMA and the U.S. military to address containing the damage done to the coastal communities along the gulf. BP is being held fully responsible and there is legislation underway to ensure they meet their fiduciary duties to provide economic relief and compensation to the hundreds of jobs affected and lost.

Attacks on the right of the political spectrum have claimed Barack Obama was not angry enough. My concern is not that the president shows emotion – but to demonstrate skillful leadership that gets results. His actions over the past two weeks reflect both. He has visited the Gulf three times and is planning a fourth trip this week. His domestic policy team are working around the clock to provide constant updates of the disaster and BP’s intended solutions.

The press should, as it has been, continue to keep the White House accountable. But let us not become so deluded as to believe that the effects and response to this present condition are comparable in scope and failure to the devastation that Katrina wrought and which remains to this day: a deadly storm met with a silent response and ineffective leadership.

Photo Source: AP Photo/Charlie Riedel, File/AP Photo/Eric Gay

Check out more stories @ The Grio!

Like Us On Facebook Follow Us On Twitter
  • The crude oil is toxic!! Workers cleaning the oily Gulf beaches need to know the danger. Don’t become BP’s Collateral Damaged, like Exxon’s Collateral Damaged.


    My name is Merle Savage, a female general foreman during the Exxon Valdez oil spill (EVOS) beach cleanup in 1989. I am one of the 11,000+ cleanup workers from the Exxon Valdez oil spill (EVOS), who is suffering from health issues from that toxic cleanup, without compensation from Exxon.

    Dr. Riki Ott visited me in 2007 to explain about the toxic spraying on the beaches. She also informed me that Exxon’s medical records and the reports that surfaced in litigation by sick workers in 1994, had been sealed from the public, making it impossible to hold Exxon responsible for their actions.

    Exxon developed the toxic spraying; OSHA, the Coast Guard, and the state of Alaska authorized the procedure. Beach crews breathed in crude oil that splashed off the rocks and into the air — the toxic exposure turned into chronic breathing conditions and central nervous system problems, neurological impairment, chronic respiratory disease, leukemia, lymphoma, brain tumors, liver damage, and blood disease.

    My web site is devoted to searching for EVOS cleanup workers who were exposed to the toxic spraying, and are suffering from the same illnesses that I have. There is an on going Longshoreman’s claim for workers with medical problems from the oil cleanup. Our summer employment turned into a death sentence for many — and a life of unending medical conditions for the rest of Exxon’s Collateral Damaged.

  • Eve

    I can understand how people would compare it, but they’re incomparable. Simple as that. And this whole “I want to see Obama get mad” bit is ridiculous; it’s almost a catch 22 because if he does, then they’ll dub him as the “angry black man”. But why should he go out of his calm character to appease others?