My white girlfriend and I used to be workout partners. We did the same workout day in and day out. Pretty much stuck to the same eating habits, but weight was dropping off her quicker, and I couldn’t understand why.  At one workout session we both went up to our trainer to get weighed in.  Once again, disappointment. But then the trainer made a comment that stuck with me forever. He said there’s a stark difference in the way black and white bodies work. Although she lost more weight, I gained more muscle.  To hell with your Barbie body, I’m She-Ra.  I’m not sure what research he was into back then, but he mentioned metabolic differences.  Maybe 10 years ago he was on to something.


A recent study done by the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine examined the metabolic differences between black and white women when it comes to weight loss.  The study, lead by James P. DeLany, Ph.d, concluded that black women may need to eat fewer calories or burn more than white women to lose the same amount of weight.  Previous studies just assumed that black women weren’t working hard enough, i.e, we were lazy.

“At first, it was thought that perhaps the African-American women didn’t adhere as closely to their calorie prescriptions or that the interventions were not culturally sensitive,” DeLany said. “But even in research projects that were designed to address those possibilities, the difference in weight loss remained.”

The six-month study involved  examining the weight changes, energy usage, activity and energy intake among 39 obese black women and 66 white women.  The researchers found that the black women lost about seven pounds fewer than the Caucasian women, even they shared a comparable BMI and followed the same calorie restrictions and exercise guidelines. But the black women had lower resting metabolic rates and expended less energy daily than the other group.

“We prescribe how many calories are allowed and how much activity is needed during weight loss interventions based on the premise that people of the same weight have similar metabolic rates,” Dr. DeLany explained. “But to account for their lower metabolic rate, African-American women must further reduce the number of calories they eat or use up more of them with exercise in order to lose the same number of pounds in the same time span as a Caucasian woman of the same weight.”

So the good news is that we’re not lazy. The bad news, we’ll probably have to add 2 more miles or another set of crunches to the workout. The better news, when you slip on that new dress you’ve been trying to get into and you look at yourself in the mirror, the only word you’ll need to say is “flawless”.

Tags: , , ,
Like Us On Facebook Follow Us On Twitter
  • One difference with black bodies is we have more sodium as the weather in Africa is warmer than the northern continents, so we hold more water weight. This happens because of heat.

    • J

      Thank you, I didn`t know that.

  • Also calorie restriction in itself is completely stupid and is not a sustainable way to lose weight; you do tremendous damage to the metabolic system restricting calories.
    What alternative to calorie restriction do you suggest and I am not trying to be smart by asking you this question.

    • Calorie restriction isn’t stupid or dangerous, I mean should you be eating 5000 calories a day? It’s extreme calorie restriction that’s dangerous (eating less than 1200 calories a day). You first need to determine (or estimate) your BMR or metabolic rate and make decisions going from there.

  • I don’t think this is necessarily a bad thing nor does it automatically mean BW need to work harder; maybe we just need to work differently like focus on weight lifting and building muscle instead of doing endless cardio. Muscle is more metabolic than fat and will burn calories all day long. There are ways of building muscle so that you don’t bulk up like a Hulk. I know plenty of women however- black, white, Asian- that are afraid of entering the weight room though.

    • cla

      Black AND white women (and anyone else) should focus on weight lifting instead of endless cardio. Women can lift just like men can. It takes specific genetics/extreme hard work to REALLY bulk up even for men. However, muscle + same or greater body fat % compared to when they started will cause someone to look bulkier.

  • @ Meh

    I was asking what alternative ChelsC would suggest since she stated that calorie restriction was stupid and dangerous. I am interested because calorie restriction is all I know when it comes to weight lost and I would like to try something different.

  • I’m attractive anyway

    I will tell you why I can’t lose the weight I put on in the last 10 years: I am broke (so I eat the cheapest junk), I am depressed that I am broke and no matter how think I was, I have a booty and rack that always made it look like I was bigger than I was. There I said it and keeping it real.